When I was a kid, albeit a little older than Ella is now, I can vividly remember how brutal my father’s punishments were. Not physically, mind you. There was no spanking. No, he would talk. He would lecture. He would discuss what it was I had done wrong, and the implications of the act, both immediate and long-term, and he would make me vocalize my understanding, answer direct questions, and in general be a part of the process. And when all that was over he would keep talking for a while, making me wait patiently for the agony to end. Given a choice between that treatment and a spanking, I think I would have picked the spanking.
And what did I catch myself doing earlier today, but the exact same thing, with Ella. She had caught Dominic playing with her toys and had pushed him rather roughly away. So I walked into her room and told her to follow me, and I went on at some length about the importance of sharing and of using words to express her feelings, and acknowledged the burden and responsibility of big-sisterhood. I made her talk about what she did wrong and asked her what she thought might be a better way to handle the situation the next time. And somewhere toward the end up it I caught that look her eye, the look I knew all to well, that said “Dear Lord in heaven, if there is any thing that I can say or do that will make him stop talking, by all that is holy in the world reveal it to me now!”