Ella and I went trick or treating on Tuesday night with her friend Abi, his parents (one of whom is my colleague at work), his aunt, and his second cousin — yes, it takes 5 adults to help 2 kids trick or treat! Nate would have gone, as well, but he was feeling under the weather. Speaking of which, we had an amazing 70 degree night to be out on the town. Having done all my childhood trick or treating in Michigan, I was completely unfamiliar with feeling too hot in the coat I wore.
Abi, Hari, and Bela invited us to join them trick or treating in their Mount Pleasant neighborhood. It’s a very racially and economically mixed DC neighborhood, and we saw a little bit of everything. While we were still at their house, two kids came up to trick or treat. Hari opened the door to reveal two boys — one in a Jason mask and the other in a creepy rubber mask. Ella immediately cowered behind my leg and started whimpering. A few days before, she saw some masks at a store in our neighborhood and decided they were very scary. One was a skeleton, so I can’t blame her for having that reaction. I tried to tell her that they were kids in masks, so she didn’t need to be scared, but she clearly wasn’t convinced.
The first house we went to was very tame, but Ella kept asking where the people in the masks went. (This became an ongoing topic of conversation throughout the evening.) I tried to urge her to walk up to the house, but she insisted that I carry her. I complied, even though I knew it was setting a horrible precedent.
We walked for another few blocks to reach one of the side streets where there was likely to be more action. Fortunately, Ella agreed to walk. For a couple blocks, she even held Abi’s hand and seemed excited about the prospect of trick or treating. The next few houses went fine, but then we heard the loud music and spooky noises coming from the last house on the block. The house had streamers hanging in front of the door, and all the windows were dark. I told Ella we didn’t have to go up to the house, but I stopped on the sidewalk in front because Abi wanted to go up. Ella (who was in my arms again at this point) was burying her head in my neck and urging me to keep moving. There was a convenience store on the corner with its door open, and she insisted that we go inside. I didn’t think they were giving out candy, so I proposed that we wait in front for Abi and Hari to catch up. She kept saying, “No, no, no. We have to keep moving, mama.” She wouldn’t let up until we were half a block away from the house. Even then, she had her hands up at the side of her face — practically covering her eyes. She barely whispered trick or treat and thanks to the people who were standing outside with their candy bowls.
By this time, I had been carrying her for quite a distance. Fortunately, Hari asked Ella if he could hold her. I didn’t think she’d comply, but she did. After walking another block, she seemed to finally recover from the scary house and resume her interest in trick or treating.
We spent most of the evening on this amazing street (Lamont) where they were having a Halloween block party. They had blocked off the street to traffic, so there were people walking everywhere. Nearly every house was decorated and had costumed people sitting out on the steps handing out candy. Everyone was having a great time. We adults were all remarking that we had had nothing like this growing up in our respective suburbs of Chicago and Holland.
Through it all, Ella ping-ponged between enjoying herself and being completely scared. We were sometimes able to coax her to walk up to a house on her own, but a few feet later she would see a scary mask, and insist on being carried again. Trying to look at it all objectively, I could empathize with her trauma. There were bizarre people walking everywhere (many of them with very convincing masks), and I was insisting that she walk up to houses and say trick or treat to complete strangers.
After finishing both sides of Lamont, we decided to walk back home. I hoisted Ella up on my shoulders. I expected that she would object, but she seemed to like the vantage point. As soon as I I told her we were heading back to Abi’s house, she perked right up and said, “I had a great time, mama.” I couldn’t believe it! It was like all the trauma of the evening washed away, and all she could think about was getting back to play with Abi’s toys. We stayed there for dinner and, even though it was an hour past her bedtime, she played intensely and was sad to go home.
She immediately fell sound asleep in the car, but woke again when she saw Nate at home. As he changed her diaper and put on her PJs, she eagerly told him about all the events of the night. We had to read her a book and sing songs to settle her down again.
The next morning, all she could talk about was how next year she is going to take her little brother trick or treating. She insisted that he would also be scared of the house, but that she would hold his hand. I can’t wait!