Example One: A few days ago, at the checkout line in the grocery store, Ella dropped her black plastic spoon. It clattered to a stop at the feet of the checkout lady, and from her perch in the cart, Ella craned her neck to try to spot it. The checkout lady bent down and picked it up.
“Thanks!” I said. “I’ll take it back. It’s her favorite toy.”
But she hesitated. She looked at the spoon, then at me. “It’s awfully dirty down there,” she said.
“I’ll wash it off at home,” I replied. Immediately I felt that little twinge of resentment, now becoming familiar, that strikes whenever I come across someone (usually a stranger) who wants to do a little bit of parenting for me. I shouldn’t have had to say that I was going to wash off the spoon, but I realized it’d be the quickest way to get the spoon back and be on my way.
Still, she hesitated. “It’s really dirty,” she said again. It became clear that she _wanted_ to throw the spoon away.
“What’s your problem, lady? Do you think I’m going to secretly stick the dirty spoon in my daughter’s mouth as soon as I’m out the door? Or that maybe I’ll be a lackluster spoonwasher once I get home? And what freakin’ business is it of yours, anyway?”
That’s what I thought about saying, but didn’t. Instead I just waited her out — it’s not like she could actually refuse to return the spoon, which she realized after a couple seconds, and handed it back with some reluctance.
Example Two: Yesterday it rained heavily all morning and into the afternoon, so by the time it finally stopped, Ella and I were good and ready for a walk. I took along the rain tarp for the stroller and made sure there was a blanket in the diaper bag in case it got chilly. As we came out of the elevator, a woman who lives in our building (and a big fan of Ella) stopped to say hello. After trying to make Ella smile for a bit, she took a step back.
“Where are you going?” she asked, somewhat incredulously. It was still cloudy outside, and a little damp.
“For a walk,” I replied. There went that twinge again.
“Oh . . .” she said. She bent down to talk to Ella again. “Is daddy taking you for a leetle WALK? In those leettle cutesy bare FEET? I hope you don’t get co-old! I hope daddy has a sweater and a blanket for you!” — at this point she peeked around to the little storage basket beneath the seat of the stroller, apparently to see if there was a sweater and a blanket in there, which there weren’t because they were in the diaper bag — “So you watch out for the ra-ain, don’t get raindrops on those little FEET!”
On principal, I didn’t point out that we were well equipped in case it rained, or that it was eighty degrees outside despite the rain. As I headed off down the hallway toward the exit, the lady called out to me: “Sometimes it seems warm because you’re walking but remember that the baby isn’t!”
Armchair parents really annoy me, especially when they’re strangers, or when they pull the whole critiquing-the-parent-by-talking-to-the-child routine. I realize that many of them mean well, but that fact doesn’t outbalance the stupendous lack of sensitivity, or the fact that those of them who are themselves parents should know better.
What I wonder is to what extent my role as the father and not the mother plays into it all. On my side, I know it makes a difference — I’m more touchy about these little passive critiques because I’m aware that my role is, in society’s eyes, nonstandard. (I wish I had a dollar for every time a stranger admiring Ella said to me “Babysitting today?” or “Is today your day with the baby?” or “Where’s her mother?”) So what I’m really wondering is whether other people are more apt to proffer unwanted advice because I’m a man, not a woman. It’s a hard thing to measure; I’m sure all parents have to put up with this stuff, so how do you tell if men have to put up with it more? Further anecdotes and/or hard research data are welcome.